Back

Target value design: designing to a budget

Target value design: designing to a budget

Target value design: designing to a budget

Team Arcol


Target value design (TVD) is a lean-construction practice where the budget is fixed first and the design is steered to hit it, instead of pricing the design after it is created.

It is the closest idea the industry already has to constructible design. The difference is that TVD has mostly survived as a meeting cadence, because no design tool could show the team the estimated cost while they designed.

What is target value design in construction?

Target value design in construction sets the owner’s allowable cost as the design target, then runs continuous estimating against the evolving scheme so cost steers decisions rather than auditing them. It came out of lean construction and integrated project delivery, where designers, builders and trade partners sit in the same room and are paid to hit the same number.

The principle is simple: cost is a design input. Arcol’s position is the same: cost is not a constraint on design, it’s an input.

Why does target value design break down in practice?

TVD breaks down because the estimate still lags the design by days, so the “target” becomes a retrospective check instead of a live lever. Design moves in hours. The costs and estimting logic live in a separate tool, with quantities taken off from drawings, and estimates delivered when the design scheme has already moved on.

“If I want to cut down five percent cost, bring me a scenario. It should give me three, four different options. This should be a matter of hours or minutes, not days.”

VP of Preconstruction, regional general contractor

Target value design lean construction teams know this. The workaround is more meetings and more estimators. Neither closes the gap.

How does constructible design make TVD native?

Constructible design puts cost inside the design model as a metric that updates on every move, so the target is visible at the moment the decision is made, not at the next cost review.


TVD as practiced

TVD in a connected model

Where cost lives

Estimator’s spreadsheet or cost tool

Inside the design app

Update cycle

Days per estimate

Every edit

Target visibility

At milestones and cluster meetings

Continuously, to designer and estimator

Who sees it first

Estimator

Everyone in the model

In Arcol, live metrics for building form, program, construction quantities, and cost move with the massing, and boards keep the target number on the same page as the design. The team still runs TVD. The tool just stops fighting it.

FAQ

Is target value design the same as value engineering? No. TVD designs to a number before the scheme is set. Value engineering cuts after it is set, which is why we call VE a receipt, not a phase.

Does target value design require integrated project delivery? No. IPD makes the incentives line up, but any team that keeps cost in the model from the first massing move is practicing it.

What does TVD need from the design tool? Cost and quantities that update with the geometry, visible to both the designer and the estimator without an export.